Matthew Sinclair argues against national pay deals while Stefan Stern says regional approach is fraught with problemsMatthew Sinclair, director of the Taxpayers’ AllianceEnding centralised pay bargaining would mean bigger value for taxpayers, bigger services for those who rely on them, and a fairer deal for public sector workers overall.The Office for National Statistics has estimated that, after accounting for “differences in the types of job and characteristics of employees”, public sector pay is 7.8% higher than private sector pay. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has place the public sector pay premium at 8.3% across the nation. However that hides huge regional variations, with “no evidence of a premium in the south-east of England, while in Wales the estimated premium is 18% for men and 18.5% for women.”Such a generous premium in some areas is clearly a terrible deal for taxpayers. It is also extremely harmful for the economies in the lower-cost, lower-income regions as community companies can’t compete with the generous national public sector pay deals to get the fair staff. Over age that method an anaemic private sector and an increasing dependence on public spending.National pay deals can constitute much more dramatic harms in the higher-cost, higher-income regions. Research by the Centre for Economics at the London College of Economics has found that national pay deals can mean worse public services. They tested the hypothesis that in areas with higher incomes outside the NHS, hospitals “suffer from problems of recruiting, retaining and motivating high quality workers. A 10% increase in the outside wage is associated with a 4% to 8% increase in [heart attack] death rates”. Pay regulation can kill. Regional public-sector pay deals would also be fairer to the workers.There is no cause workers in some regions should get an arbitrary windfall, and others unnecessary hardship, simply since of the quirks of national pay bargaining.Stefan Stern, visiting professor of management practice at Cass Business College, LondonCan a “one nation” party support regional pay differentials in the public sector? The chancellor would probably affirm that it can – just since it is called the “National Health Supply” doesn’t mean that human beings doing the same job in different parts of the nation should receive the same pay.In making this condition the administration might mark to parts of the private sector where pay varies according to region. Greggs the bakers, for example, uses top-up “location allowances” of 25 and 50p an hour, which it targets on dense recruiting areas, according to Incomes Data Services, the research corporation.There are a abundance of potential problems here. Unions and employers have traditionally reached national pay deals for a cause. They are the “least worst option” from everybody’s mark of view.What signal would a relative lowering of public sector pay send to human beings in the regions? That their employment was worth less? And how would private sector employers react? Would they learn fresh depths of generosity and choose to boost the pay they offer? Or would they rather feel that the community market rate was immediately falling, and that they also could hold down pay? The sluggish UK economy needs more demand, not less. It is dense to see how paying human beings less will encourage growth.As the Harvard philosopher Michael Sandel writes in the April issue of The Atlantic: “A market economy is a tool – a valuable and effective tool – for organising productive activity. A market society is a path of lifetime in which market values seep into every aspect of human endeavour.”If we really are “all in this together” we probably demand more rather than fewer national benchmarks. Artificial competition and destructive “market forces” should probably be kept outside of national pay deals.Civil servicePublic sector payPublic services policyGeorge OsborneBudgetTax and spendingEconomic policyMatthew SinclairStefan Sternguardian.co.uk © 2012 Twitter News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Employ of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds
DOWNLOAD: Frozen Planet